A Big to Small Model: How to Evaluate, Engage, and Develop Effective Small Business Partnerships
Glenn Henderson & Jim Chambers, EdD
Impossible Business Solutions (IBS)
Introduction
According to the Cruise Lines International Association (CLIA), more than 35 million passengers set sail on cruise ships annually. Much of this success is due to the popularity of theme-based cruises, onboard entertainment, quality service, and affordable prices.
While the cruise ship itself has everything you need for a great trip, the journey is incomplete without excursions to shallow waters, wildlife habitats, historical sites, shopping venues, unique landscapes, and more. The challenge, of course, is that cruise ships cannot offer access to these destinations without the help of smaller vessels, which is why the Zodiac, a small, agile inflatable, has become one of the most valuable resources in the cruise line industry.
Like cruise ships, large corporations succeed because they provide consumers with access to a wide range of popular products and services at competitive prices. And, like their big ocean-going counterparts, corporations cannot effectively deliver on their promises without the help of smaller and more agile small business partners. As a result, small businesses, like the Zodiac inflatable, have become an indispensable resource in today’s global economy.
The Challenge
When a cruise ship wants to expand its shallow water excursions, it simply contacts Zodiac Nautic and orders more vessels. Zodiacs are typically in stock and ship almost immediately.
When a large corporation wants to leverage the abilities of a small business to fulfill customer needs, it must sort through thousands of small businesses to find the right strategic partner. This is a monumental task, and even when they narrow it down, they don’t always have a formal assessment process to determine which businesses meet their specific needs or are the best return on investment.
This challenge is exacerbated by the fact that small businesses now represent approximately 46% of the US workforce (bls.gov) and employ some of the brightest and best people in every industry. If a large corporation wants to leverage these resources, they must have an effective way to evaluate, engage, and develop their business partners. And if they don’t, the competition certainly will.
It’s Not a Simple Task
Corporate leaders tasked with finding qualified small business partners are faced with an expensive, complex, and time-consuming process. It’s not a simple task.
There are thousands of small businesses seeking partnerships with large corporations, but there is no proven strategy or guidelines on how to guarantee the right match. To make matters worse, even corporations that rely heavily on small businesses typically lack a best-practice model for developing them long-term, so the small business aspect is a revolving door.
While there are several programs and certifications to qualify potential small business partners, they rely heavily on traditional metrics related to organization, structure, operations, financial, legal, and scope of services. Unfortunately, that is not enough.
Our research shows that traditional data alone does not provide enough information to determine if a small business is a good fit, especially at the values level. In fact, there is no evidence that using traditional metrics increases success, which puts corporations that depend on these partnerships at even greater risk.
The truth is, it is not a simple task to find and keep the right small business partners, and horror stories of lost revenue, angry customers, and damaged reputations due to bad partnerships would fill a library.
The Solution
Evaluate, Engage, Develop
If the use of traditional metrics alone does not work, what does? How can a large corporation evaluate, engage, and develop a relationship with small businesses without putting themselves and their customers at risk?
In our view, the solution is not to dismiss traditional metrics, but to use the data as part of a formal three-stage process:
Stage 1: Evaluation
In addition to traditional metrics, IBS offers a scenario-based, value-driven evaluation to determine how a small business will function in a corporate partnership role.
IBS uses real-world scenarios that every small business will face while engaged in partnership with a larger corporation. This includes value-based decisions, attitudes, scope, and operational factors that can increase risk, disrupt product development and supply chains, or, worse, cause disruption.
A focus on core values also clarifies any gaps between the leadership, management, and operational practices that would put the corporation or its customers at risk. IBS lets corporate leadership identify what areas need attention if they decide to go forward, and how to fill those gaps.
Stage 2: Engagement
Once a potential small business partner has been qualified beyond the initial metrics, the IBS evaluation enables the corporation to engage the small business owners/leaders in a meaningful conversation about how they will work together.
This involves a series of face-to-face meetings designed to identify the right partners, agree on strengths and weaknesses, establish goals, review performance standards, and clarify expectations. This helps both parties determine the best roadmap going forward.
Stage 3: Development
For the partnership to go forward, the small business agrees to enter a development process designed to acclimate them to a larger corporate culture, and close leadership, financial, legal, technology, and operational gaps. The development process is designed to strengthen, grow, and promote mutual, long-term success.
Because the process requires both parties to invest time, energy, and resources, it also becomes an ongoing resource for evaluating, engaging, and developing successful small business partnerships that match the corporate needs and culture. In some cases, it can even define the standard for an industry going forward.
Next Steps
To learn more about how to evaluate, engage, and develop small business partnerships, contact Impossible Business Solutions (IBS).
Glenn S. Henderson
Glenn Henderson is a distinguished entrepreneur and philanthropist who shares his life lessons in books, blogs, podcasts, and speaking engagements for businesses, organizations, colleges, universities, and religious groups nationally and globally.
Jim Chambers, EdD
Dr. Jim Chambers is a professional educator with a reputation for designing, developing, and implementing effective enterprise-wide learning initiatives involving leadership, management, organization, and executive coaching in the US and abroad.
Contact Us: info@businessofpossible.com